An Update on CDOT’s Bikeway Construction

A crew installs buffered bike lanes on Madison Street. Photo: CDOT

We’re currently in the midst of a bike lane building boom. Earlier this year the Chicago Department of Transportation completed groundbreaking protected lanes on Milwaukee from Kinzie to Elston, which involved removing about 50 percent of the parking spaces. Buffered lanes were striped on Wells from Chicago to North. Recently CDOT completed buffered lanes on a two-mile stretch of Madison between Pulaski and Central, and this week the department began or continued installation of the following 11 miles of bikeways:

  • Clybourn (North to Belmont): 2.8 miles of buffered lanes — construction was slated to end today
  • Vincennes (103rd to 84th): 2.65 miles of protected and buffered lanes — striping was slated to end today, flexible posts will be installed in the near future
  • Kedzie (North to Palmer): .75 miles of buffered lanes — construction started this week
  • Archer (State to Cermak): .60 miles of buffered lanes — construction started this week
  • Halsted (Garfield to Pershing): two miles of buffered lanes — construction started this week
  • Berteau (Lincoln to Clark): .85 miles of neighborhood greenway — construction ongoing
  • South Shore (79th to 71st): 1.25 miles of buffered bike lanes — construction started this week

It’s worth noting that all of Clybourn and South Shore, most of Archer, and the southernmost three blocks of Vincennes are state jurisdiction roads. The Illinois Department of Transportation has prohibited the city of Chicago from installing protected lanes on IDOT streets, citing safety concerns. The real reasons for the ban aren’t clear yet, but an email obtained from CDOT via a Freedom of Information Act Request indicated that concern for cyclist’s safety wasn’t one of them.

Active Trans' Bikeways Tracker map. Proposed projects are red; projects under construction are purple; completed projects are blue.

In addition to the roughly 15 miles — about four of them protected — completed or under construction this year, CDOT had a bid opening this week for a federally-funded project to build 15 more miles of buffered lanes this year. The department hopes to complete 35 miles of buffered and protected lanes in 2013, for a total of 65 miles — 20-25 of them protected — installed since Mayor Rahm Emanuel took office in May 2011. The current goal is to install 100 miles of protected and buffered lanes by May of 2015. This means CDOT will really need to hustle to get the last 35 miles in next spring.

I recently sat down with CDOT Project Manager Mike Amsden to discuss these projects. The department currently refers to protected lanes as “barrier-protected” and buffered lanes as “buffer-protected.” For simplicity, I have altered his quotes to include the more commonly used terms.

Amsden says he’s particularly excited about the bikeway on Vincennes, which is designated as a Spoke Route in the city’s Streets for Cycling Plan 2020. While conventional bike lanes previously existed on this stretch, CDOT removed them to increase motor vehicle capacity on the street during the Dan Ryan Expressway reconstruction from 2006 to 2008. In general, the southbound bike lane will be buffered with curbside car parking; the northbound lane will be curbside with a painted buffer to the left plus flexible posts that will discourage, but not prevent, drivers from entering the bike lane.

Mike Amsden
Mike Amsden on a Bikes Belong research trip in Amsterdam. Photo: Bikes Belong

He said that with improvements for pedestrians, bicyclists and motorists, Vincennes will truly become a complete street. “Vincennes is really what we’re trying to do as a department, making streets safer for everybody,” he said. “We’ve done a lot of data collection out on Vincennes, we’ve met with a couple of people in the community and the alderman, and speeding is the number one concern out there.”

There were 981 reported crashes, with 25 serious injuries ands three fatalities, on this street between 2006 and 2010. Speed measurements taken last year at 92nd and Vincennes found that 63 percent of southbound motorists and 86 percent of northbound drivers were speeding. Sixteen percent of the southbound motorists were traveling above 40 mph, and 41 percent of the northbound ones were. “That’s incredibly fast and incredibly dangerous,” Amsden said.

The new configuration will act as a road diet by narrowing the car lanes, which will calm traffic and shortening pedestrian crossing distances. CDOT will also install high-visibility crosswalks, pedestrian refuge space, and turn lanes for motorists. “There’s not a lot of traffic out there right now, and it’s kind of this wide, open undefined space,” Amsden said. “At times [the broad two-lane street] would act as two lanes in each direction, so we’re clearly marking it as one lane in each direction.” He said CDOT hopes to eventually build bike lanes on Vincennes from the southern border of the city all the way to its northern terminus at State.

New buffered lane on Clybourn. Photo: CDOT

The Archer bike lane installation will include a more dramatic road diet, converting four lanes to three. The Halsted project mostly involves a two-lane roadway, but a quarter-mile segment in the middle of this stretch that currently has four lanes will undergo a four-to-three conversion to make it consistent with of the rest of the roadway.

Kedzie currently has conventional bike lanes for most of the project area, but they drop out between Moffat and Armitage to make room for four lanes of car traffic with shared lane markings. “That was done a few years back when maintaining auto capacity was the norm,” Amsden explained. “We had a request from [26th ward Alderman Roberto] Maldonado to make it better for bikes. He didn’t like the fact that you had a bike lane that disappeared and then the bike lane came out.” That’s interesting because, at Maldonado’s request, bikes were not accommodated in a 2010 road diet on nearby Humboldt Boulevard. Hopefully this means alderman has become more bike-friendly in recent years. The whole segment of Kedzie will be converted to two travel lanes with buffered bike lanes.

Steven Vance has noted that at several of the intersections on Clybourn, which would have been wide enough for protected lanes were it not for the IDOT ban, the new buffered lanes disappear well before you get to an intersection. “These are IDOT routes, so there are different requirements we need to meet on their roadways,” Amsdem explained. “So at times, depending on the amount of traffic volume and the amount of turning motorists at certain intersections, turn lanes need to be a certain length, and that’s usually [why the bike lanes drop out].”

When Emanuel stated his goal of building 100 miles of protected bike lanes within his first term in his Chicago 2011 Transition Plan, protected lanes were defined as “separated from traveling cars and sit[ing] between the sidewalk and a row of parked cars that shield cyclists from street traffic.” I asked Amsden about the fact that the vast majority of these new projects are buffered, not protected lanes.

After residents complained, CDOT blocked the protected lanes on Independence with barricades, then downgraded them to buffered lanes. Photo: John Greenfield

In addition to the obstacle of the IDOT ban, Amsden seemed to say that some parts of the city that don’t already have high ridership aren’t ready for protected bike lanes. “Many of these projects are in parts of the city where we don’t have a lot of bike infrastructure yet,” he said. “We’ve heard on a regular basis when we’re talking to stakeholders in these communities that, ‘You need to walk before you can run.’ So taking out parking and taking out travel lanes, it’s not always going to work in some neighborhoods, but putting in a buffered lane is a great start. It can help get people out riding and start that mode shift. You can’t always go full blast and put in something that’s great for bikes when you don’t have the ridership yet.”

For example, last year CDOT ran into trouble when local residents complained to 24th Ward Alderman Michael Chandler after the department relocated parking for protected bike lanes on Independence Boulevard. Although the alderman had previously approved the lanes, he insisted that they be removed, and CDOT agreed to downgrade them to buffered lanes. “We may have pushed the envelop a little bit and we probably could have done [outreach] better and been successful in pushing the envelope, but we learned our lesson,” Amsden said.

CDOT’s hard work getting in many miles of buffered bike lanes installed this summer is laudable, and it’s certainly more of a challenge to reconfigure the street for protected lanes in neighborhoods that aren’t already bike-friendly. However, if we’re serious about getting more risk-averse people to try transportation cycling, it’s important to install as many “eight to eighty” facilities, which provide physical protection from cars, as possible. Hopefully in the future we’ll see the department do the necessary outreach and push a little harder to install more protected bike lanes all over the city.

Streetsblog Chicago will not be publishing on Monday. Have a great Labor Day!

  • Anna

    Glad to hear about buffered lanes going in on Halsted and Archer. But what about the missing bike lane on southwest-bound Archer west of Canal? I emailed CDOT about this on January 6 and received a reply on January 17 from Charlie Short at Active Trans saying, “Pavement markings were installed incorrectly by the contractor. We aware of the situation and it will be fixed when weather allows.” I sent a followup email on June 18, figuring sometime between January 17 and June 18 the weather should’ve been nice enough to install thermoplastic. I never received a reply, and there’s still no bike lane there. I’m happy to take the lane, but, judging by the honking, motorists are not so happy about me taking the lane between Canal and Halsted.

  • David Altenburg

    I live right off of Kedzie, so I was pleasantly surprised to find the bike lanes being striped there this week. I think that once the Bloomingdale Trail is open next year, Kedzie will become an important route to connect the trail with Logan Square. As it stands, however, the lane on Kedzie doesn’t really take you anywhere. At the south end, it terminates at North Avenue, an IDOT-controlled road that is really harrowing to bike along. At the north, it’ll get you to Palmer, but if you’re riding in that direction, you’re probably headed to somewhere near Milwaukee Avenue. I guess my point is, that if CDOT had extended the Kedzie lane a bit further north and south, it would be several times more useful, and I wonder why they did not.

  • Kevin M

    I agree with you, David.

    I am a homeowner on Kedzie, between Palmer and Logan, and I believe that this section of Kedzie needs a road diet. Drivers routinely exceed the speed limit, and it is nearly impossible to cross Kedzie between Logan & Palmer except for at Fullerton. I’d like to see a protected bike lane installed and one automobile lane
    removed in each direction on Kedzie, between Palmer & Logan.

  • WanderBikes™

    We couldn’t be more excited about Chicago’s new bike path plans. Everybody is going to have their two cents of where the paths should go and connect. However, it’s more important that Chicago is experiencing a city-transportation paradigm shift.

  • The section of Archer between Canal and Halsted is a speedway and should have received a road diet as part of the recent resurfacing. You don’t need 4 motor vehicle lanes on a road with an average daily traffic count of only 13,300 vehicles. This results in traffic, including even CTA buses, regularly exceeding 40mph.

    I hadn’t notice that the southbound bike lane was never reinstalled, but I did see that the northbound lane (a measly 4-foot wide lane that’s often blocked by parked cars) has been missing bike lane symbols.

  • I was surprised by how Clybourn’s lanes disappear so far in advance of an intersection. A large majority of bike-automobile crashes occur at intersections, but even NACTO’s own guidelines promote concepts like “mixing zones” that result in dangerous conditions for cyclists. We won’t have true “8 to 80” infrastructure until we do a better job at intersection design.

  • Lawrence’s bus lanes west of Pulaski are almost entirely rubbed off. The intersection of Kostner and Lawrence was recently resurfaced, and CDOT painted in nice wide zebra bars, but did NOT repaint the bike lane lines on the new asphalt, much less put the ‘bike’ icons back in on nearby sections of street where they’re worn off.

  • I get excited when I see the progress. But there are two things:

    1. Looking at that Active Trans map, notice how disconnected the lanes are. The new infrastructure does nothing unless you can reasonably travel a few miles on the exact same type of infrastructure by bike. That is – if you have a protected lane on Dearborn, don’t make it stop at Kinzie. Take it all the way up to North Av where you can at least get to the LFT. Imagine if the roadways were disconnected like this.

    2. Protected bike lanes are key. I talk to so many people who just don’t want to ride a bike because the lanes aren’t connected, they don’t know where it’s safe to bike (and there’s really no good way to find out except by talking to others), and the infrastructure doesn’t take the unique aspects of riding a bike into account. A specific example is intersections and turns. If the lane ends before an intersection it is almost useless in navigation or helping people on bikes.

  • Julia

    I was going to comment on the same. I ride on Clybourn between Diversey and Fullerton daily, and was hit yesterday in one of these non-marked sections before the intersection at Wrightwood. While it wasn’t a terrible accident (right hook, nothing broken on me or bike), it’s incredibly frustrating that IDOT is knowingly blocking better cycling infrastructure. I hope at least my intersection-related accident will help boost the statistics in support of better bike lanes.

  • Julia

    Count me in agreement as well! I live in Logan as well and like to take Kedzie southbound, instead of Sacramento or California. There seem to be more people taking the lane on the inside of the boulevard, but the speed issues are still prevalent.

  • Greg Borzo

    An excellent update. Cyclists now need to use these lanes early and often to prove they are needed and helpful…and to convince Chicagoans in parts of town that are not yet bike friendly that protected laves are the best way to go.

  • Cklaus

    I would support more speed cameras on the four lane stretches of Humboldt and Kedzie. As a driver, I appreciate the ability to turn off my side street onto a thoroughfare that moves. I worry if there’s too much road dieting, we may end up with 5 hrs of daily gridlock. Speeders need tickets, though, definitely.

  • Thanks Greg! Looking forward to the Chicago release party for your new book on RAGBRAI at a date and location TBD.

  • Adam Herstein

    I find it very hard to believe that buffered lanes will get more people riding.

  • Adam Herstein

    If the lane ends before an intersection it is almost useless in navigation or helping people on bikes.

    These so-called “mixing zones” are terrible design.

  • Anonymous

    Why? I really enjoy having more room between me and both the door zone and the “car zone.” I can imagine a tentative prospective cyclist feeling similarly.

  • Adam Herstein

    In my opinion, buffered bike lanes only offer a marginal improvement over conventional bike lanes – not to mention many of them just disappear at intersections. If getting more people biking is desired, separated cycle tracks are the way to go.

  • Anne A

    In some locations, such as Vincennes, it can make a difference.

  • Anne A

    Re: Vincennes: “Sixteen percent of the northbound motorists were traveling above 40 mph, and 41 percent of the southbound ones were.” That combination surprises me. With railroad tracks and few intersections along much of the northbound side, I would have expected the northbound percentage of excessive speeders to be higher..

  • Anna Schibrowsky

    Tonight I saw new buffered lane markings on southbound Halsted between Archer and 29th. :-)


Eyes on the Street: New Bike Lanes on the North Side

This is the time of year when the Chicago Department of Transportation hustles to get the last of the new bikeways installed before it’s too cold to stripe thermoplastic. Since the threshold is 50 degrees Fahrenheit, this week’s cold snap could mean the end of the construction season. Hopefully, this year, CDOT won’t attempt to […]

CDOT Has a Full Plate of New and Upgraded Bike Lane Infrastructure

During last week’s Mayor’s Bicycle Advisory Council meeting Chicago Department of Transportation staffers shared a number of updates on the city’s bike network. At the event, CDOT planner Mike Amsden, who manages the department’s bikeways program, explained how funds from Blue Cross Blue Shield’s $12 million sponsorship of the Divvy bike-share system are helping to pay for bike […]

Hamstrung by IDOT, City Plans Buffered Lanes Where Cann Was Killed

Last Thursday, about a week after the May 29th death of cyclist Robert “Bobby” Cann, killed by an allegedly drunk, speeding driver at Clybourn and Larrabee, the Chicago Department of Transportation announced plans to stripe buffered bike lanes on the entire 3.5-mile length of Clybourn, from Division to Belmont. Construction should start either this week […]

Chicago Building Four Miles of Protected Bike Lanes This Year

The City of Chicago announced a new slate of bikeway projects today, outlining about 15 miles of new buffered bike lanes and a little more than four miles of protected lanes to be built in 2014. Under the plan for this year, protected bikeway construction in Chicago would continue to outpace every other American city except […]