What’s the Rationale Behind the Concrete Protection at Randolph/Dearborn?
Randolph & Dearborn in Chicago. Gotta love the intersection of two protected bike lanes, with a Dutch-inspired intersection treatment. -JG pic.twitter.com/CYwIuZfgvG
— Streetsblog Chicago (@streetsblogchi) November 30, 2016
The other day I was eating lunch at the Latinicity food court (try the arroz aeropuerto) on the third floor of the Block 37 building when I noticed there was a nice view of the intersection of the Dearborn Street two-way protected bike lane, as well as the recently installed Randolph protected lane. Both sides of the northwest corner of the junction have concrete infrastructure inspired by Dutch protected intersections.
It can often be a frustrating, or even frightening, experience to ride a bike on the streets of Chicago. Our bikeway are often clogged with illegally parked vehicles, torn up for utility work, or dangerously obstructed by construction projects, and reckless driving is widespread.
But the view was a reminder that, for all of the challenges that face Chicago cyclists, there are a lot of good initiatives happening to improve biking here. I snapped a photo of two Divvy riders in the intersection and posted it on Twitter, where it quickly racked up hundreds of “likes” and retweets.
And THIS is cool… @Trailnet @StlStreets @MayorSlay @nextSTL can we get some of these soon? #AllIWantForChristmas #prettyplease https://t.co/wDwy5U17gw — Andrew Murray (@AndrewZMurray) November 30, 2016
Praise for the infrastructure poured in from Cincinnati, St. Louis (see the tweet above), Kansas City, Philadelphia, New York, Boston, Atlanta, Miami, Houston, Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, San Diego, Toronto, Mexico City, Lagos, Madrid, Paris, and London. Many of the retweets were by bike advocates urging their local officials to experiment with similar bikeway treatments. That’s not to say there weren’t some detractors.
@transitized @streetsblogchi The bi-directional Cycletrack is dangerous & inappropriate in a city environment. Long ago dumped in NL & DK — Erik (@erik_griswold) November 30, 2016
I doubt any bikeway engineer in the Netherlands would want to take responsibility for inspiring this. https://t.co/kswznAjI0g — Transitized (@transitized) November 30, 2016
And even the Green Lane Project, the nation’s leading cheerleader for protected bike lanes, was curious why the concrete islands were placed at the northwest corner, rather than the southwest. That’s the main location where there there’s a potential for conflicts between bikes and motor vehicle, since drivers have to cross the bike lane to make a left turn.
I responded that there are dedicated signal phase for northbound bike riders and turning drivers, so the Chicago Department of Transportation may have felt that further protection wasn’t necessary. In addition, I noted, there used to be an issue with pedestrians at the northwest corner standing in the Dearborn lane while waiting for a walk signal, so the pedestrian islands provide a safe place to stand.
I checked in with Mike Amsden, who manages CDOT’s bikeway program, to get the skinny on why islands were installed at the northwest corner but not the southwest corner. “The intersection concept is provided at this location to mostly assist with people riding west on Randolph who want to turn south on Dearborn,” he responded via email. “The corner refuge island provides a protected space for a person to queue on Dearborn facing south, outside of the path of people continuing west on Randolph. The pedestrian refuge islands also provide space for pedestrians to queue outside of the bike lane, and in a place much more visible to motorists.”
Amsden added that the same treatment wouldn’t work at the southwest corner because there is no “dead space” outside of a travel lane, turn lane, or the two-way bike lane where the concrete could be installed. “If the corner refuge island was shifted straight south to the southwest corner it would be directly in line with left turning motor vehicle traffic from northbound Dearborn to westbound Randolph, and directly in line with westbound traffic on Randolph in the southern most curb lane.”
“Your response… re: the left hook is spot on,” Amsden said. “The signal separation for through bike and turning car traffic provides the protection.” He acknowledged that drivers do occasionally disregard their signal. “But we know from experience in Chicago and elsewhere that the dedicated signals increase compliance for both people riding and people turning left — over 90% compliance for both (not perfect for either, but huge improvements).”
This morning one more reason for installing concrete protection at the northwest corner occurred to me. There were at least three incidents in recent years in which speeding drivers crashed into Petterino’s restaurant, located at that corner. That hasn’t happened since the Dearborn lane was installed, but you can never be too careful.