Active Trans: Rahm Should Aim for 100 Miles of Bike Lanes Again, Not 50

Emanuel and Scheinfeld and Burnett on Milwaukee Avenue
27th Ward alderman Walter Burnett (wearing the cap), CDOT commissioner Rebekah Scheinfeld, and Mayor Emanuel inspect the city’s in-progress bikeway network at last Friday’s press conference. Photo: CDOT

Last week at a press event celebrating the installation of 103 miles of buffered and protected bike lanes, Mayor Rahm Emanuel promised to build 50 miles of new bike lanes, including PBLs, over the next four years. The Active Transportation Alliance’s new “Bikeways for All” campaign, launched on Monday, urges the mayor to double that goal.

In a press release. Active Trans director Ron Burke congratulated the city for reaching the milestone, noting that, along with the Divvy system, the new lanes have transformed bicycling “into a mainstream mode of transportation.” However, the group says that, even with all the new lanes, only a third of Chicagoans who live outside of downtown have quarter-mile access to a protected lane, neighborhood greenway, or off-street trail.

The organization is asking the city to build 100 miles of these “low-stress bikeways” by 2020. “Even though the number of people cycling has multiplied, we still have a long way to go before the average person feels safe and comfortable getting on a bike to ride to work, run errands and drop off kids at school,” Burke said.

The city uses the Orwellian phrase “buffer-protected” to refer to buffered bike lanes and considers them to be a type of protected bike lane, even though they offer no physical protection. Active Trans’ 100-mile proposal wouldn’t count buffered bike lanes, but it would include existing bikeways that are upgraded to low-stress routes.

Bikeways for all: access to low-stress bike routes
The Active Transportation Alliance has called on Mayor Emanuel to focus on building more low-stress bike routes because few residents currently have quarter-mile access to them.

Active Trans says the proposal is called Bikeways for All because it “would allow people of all ages and abilities to get around efficiently and comfortably on a bike.” While’s they’re only calling for 100 miles of low-stress routes to be added by 2020, they’ve identified 180 miles of potential locations for the facilities. They say that if all 180 miles were built, 80 percent of Chicagoans would have quarter-mile access to a LSR.

While it might seem bold to propose a big expansion of the bike network in the middle of a city budget crisis, Active Trans notes that many of the bikeways could be federally funded. As it stands, the Chicago Department of Transportation mostly uses federal Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improvement grants to pay for bike projects. The Bikeways for All report states that CDOT uses less than 0.5 percent of its own budget to built bike routes.

In addition to expanding the bike network, Active Trans is asking the city to make it more equitable. The report states that while 82 percent of Chicagoans who live on the North Side have half-mile access to any type of bikeway, only 71 percent and 74 percent of those on the South and West Sides, respectively, have the same access. See a breakdown of the official community areas included in each region here.

proposed routes bikeways for all
The Active Transportation Alliance proposes upgrading buffered bike lanes to protected bike lanes, and building 180 miles of new, low-stress bike routes.

So far, the city’s implementation strategy has often been to build disconnected segments of bikeways here and there when opportunities arise, such as street repaving projects, with plans to link them up in the future. CDOT Commissioner Rebekah Scheinfeld said on Friday that increasing connectivity will be a goal for the next four years.

Bikeways for All recommends that creating a bike network that is seamless and intuitive to navigate should be a top priority. As maps in the report show, it’s currently impossible to bicycle between, or even within, neighborhoods on only low-stress routes.

Building more neighborhood greenways — routes on traffic-calmed residential streets — would be a great strategy for encouraging “interested-but-concerned” cyclists to ride more. Right now, the city only has 1.5 miles of neighborhood greenways. Both of the greenway streets are on the North Side, and neither of them involve the traffic diverters that are commonly found on other cities’ bike boulevards.

The Berteau Avenue Greenway involved lowering the speed limit to 20 m.p.h., installing a contraflow bike lane, adding curb bump-outs to calm traffic, and removing excess stop signs. Another project on Wood Street, simply added a contraflow lane, plus some shared-lane markings, a bike box, and “Bikes May Use Full Lane” signs.

One of the novel aspects of the Bikeways for All Report report is their proposal for temporarily reserving travel lanes for bikes and buses at certain times of day. For example, Milwaukee Avenue in Wicker Park gets tons of cyclists, but there isn’t enough right-of-way to build protected lanes without stripping parking.

Perhaps cars could be banned from the southbound lane during the morning rush, and from the northbound lane during the evening rush. After all, drivers can use the Kennedy Expressway or Elston Avenue as alternatives for traveling between the Northwest Side and downtown.

At the press conference for a new public bike parking facility in the West Loop on Monday, Emanuel gave a non-answer to a DNA reporter’s question on whether he will follow Active Trans’ recommendation to double his bike lane goal. Even if he doesn’t increase its mileage target, hopefully Bikeways for All will inspire CDOT to prioritize building low-stress routes and fill in network gaps.

  • kastigar

    Added bike lanes – buffer-protected, barrier-protected, or just plain bike lanes is always a good idea.

    But just as roads and bridges are infrastructure that requires maintenance, existing bike lanes need to be maintained too. Several streets that have bike lanes have been left dormant with the focus on new construction. Lawrence, between Western and Central Park and Kedzie, between Foster and Peterson are good examples where bike lanes have been allowed to fad and hard for motorists to distinguish.

    New bike lanes are silver, old bike lanes are gold.

  • After I published I realized I forgot to talk about this: maintenance.

    None of the CDOT commissioners I’ve “lived through” (Byrne, Powers, Ware, Klein, Scheinfeld) have made it a point to dedicate time and money to maintaining bike lanes *outside* of (gonna happen regardless of bike lanes) resurfacing.

    Today I was noticing that pavement markings to delineate bike lanes and shared lanes, installed no earlier than 2011, are very worn. Sometimes, like on Kinzie Street, the city has replaced these markings. Often right over low quality pavement.

    So, outside of street resurfacing projects, bike lane maintenance comes from aldermanic menu money – where it competes against a whole host of other ward issues, like street lighting, sidewalk repair, and speed humps.

  • Here is Dearborn 2 days ago, the day after the mayor held a press conference bragging about the bike lanes:

    Suffice it to say, riding over little pebbles and garbage in a gutter while dodging people from the right and cars who can’t see you from the left while you ride up a street going the wrong way is hardly what I consider low-stress.

  • Wewilliewinkleman

    From your photo its obvious their is some kind of repair going on underground. Do you suggest these repairs be stopped or moved elsewhere?

  • No I suggest that they not leave half the patch material laying in the bike lane and not hold press conferences bragging about bike lanes that look like this

  • Fibinaccignocchi

    Really? You’re bent out of shape about a little lightly dispersed gravel and a banana peel resting against the curb? Really? What are you riding, a skateboard? Maybe we need to bring crossing sweepers back so Little Lord Fauntleroy doesn’t encounter a speck of filth in his travels.

  • Not sure why you think contemptuous attacks on other regular posters are in any way a positive contribution to the site, but hey, whatever.

  • Keep it civil please. Thanks.

  • Wewilliewinkleman

    Well from your photo it looks like a fairly extensive project that includes lane reductions and large metal plates in the road. The patching material from the plates to the road surface appear normal to me. Yes it does extend into the bike lane. Must be a pretty large hole. Sometime life is inconvenient just be glad the big hole isn’t in the bike lane.

  • Wewilliewinkleman

    But, in general most street painted surfaces are not going to last beyond four years. Geeze the paint on my porch is peeling after four years. Look at the condition of crosswalks and you will get an idea of what you will see in a few years. But hey we’re getting a new ferris wheel at navy pier so all is good.

  • cjlane

    Some people would apparently prefer that they move all of the existing underground utilities out from underneath the *vicinity* of all bike lanes prior to saying anything positive in public about any bike lanes.

    I think that the natural outgrowth of that approach would be that city leaders would opt out of providing bike lanes at all.

  • You and I both own a piece of that Ferris wheel, thanks to the extra 1 percentage point of sales tax on food and beverages purchased at O’Hare, Midway, and within an extended “central area”.

  • Even if you think @bingaman:disqus offered a poor example of how bicyclists are accommodated during road works, there are plenty others that may get your attention, if you or your sister or daughter were riding in them.

    We’ve featured a handful of them on this website.

    The quality of a city’s bike lanes shouldn’t be measured in how little its residents struggle while bicycling, but by how much that infrastructure actually gets people out bicycling. In other words, that someone bicycling didn’t have to encounter anything worse than this doesn’t make it a quality bike lane.

    In the specific example, the bikeable area of the Dearborn bike lane has been decreased. This wouldn’t be “so bad” if the bike lane carried a single direction of traffic. Instead, the direction of traffic that doesn’t have this road works incursion is also affected because people bicycling in the opposite direction are going to ride around the works.


CDOT Looks Back at Chicago’s Bikeway Progress in 2012

The Chicago Department of Transportation recently gave itself a well-deserved pat on the back with the release of the 2012 Bikeways – Year in Review report. The new document does a great job of getting the message across about just how much the city accomplished last year in building new bikeways and how these improvements will benefit […]

City Begins Work on Next 50 Miles of Bikeways, Funds Bikes N’ Roses

Today at a ribbon cutting for curb-protected bike lanes on 31st Street by the Illinois Institute of Technology, Mayor Emanuel and transportation commissioner Rebekah Scheinfeld elaborated on the city’s previously announced plan to build 50 more miles of bikeways by 2019. This represents a slower pace of installation than the city’s previous achievement of installing […]

An Update on CDOT’s Bikeway Construction

We’re currently in the midst of a bike lane building boom. Earlier this year the Chicago Department of Transportation completed groundbreaking protected lanes on Milwaukee from Kinzie to Elston, which involved removing about 50 percent of the parking spaces. Buffered lanes were striped on Wells from Chicago to North. Recently CDOT completed buffered lanes on […]