Chicagoans Gave Big Support to Ped/Bike Projects in PB Elections

PB5 Vote
Voting in the 5th Ward Participatory Budgeting election. Photo courtesy of PB Chicago.

The results of last week’s participatory budgeting elections show that, when you give them a chance, Chicago residents are happy to support projects that make our streets safer, more efficient and more vibrant. The 5th, 45th, 46th and 49th wards took part in the PB process, which allows citizens to propose ideas for each district’s $1.3 million in discretionary “menu” money and then vote on the projects that make it on the final ballot. While aldermen traditionally decide how menu money is used, and normally opt for basic street, sidewalk and lighting improvements, these results mean several innovative walking, biking, transit and public space initiatives will debut in the near future.

A whopping 1,400 participants cast ballots in the Far North Side’s 49th Ward, where Alderman Joe Moore first pioneered the process in 2010. “The participatory budgeting elections have exceeded even my wildest dreams,” said Moore in a statement. “They are more than elections.  They are community celebrations and an affirmation that people will participate in the civic affairs of their community if given real power to make real decisions.”

His constituents voted to spend $30,000 on a pedestrian safety engineering study on Sheridan, which could lead to improvements like curb extensions to shorten crossing distances, and changes to stoplight and walk signal timing. They also voted to use $75,000 to install shared-lane markings for bikes on Clark from Howard to Albion. Other proposals that won funding included new sidewalks, the restoration of cobblestones on Glennwood, and cherry blossom trees and a new water fountain at Touhy Park.

In Leslie Hairston’s 5th Ward, on the south lakefront, the transportation committee for the PB process proposed 23 different projects, including many nontraditional ideas for promoting biking and transit use. However, unlike the other three aldermen, Hairston decided to designate these as “service requests” that should instead be funded by city departments, the CTA or the park district. The alderman has asked members of the committee to follow up with the relevant agencies to make sure these projects are completed, with the understanding that she has prioritized them, although she declined to fund them. However, street, sidewalk and lighting repairs, which can also be paid for by city agencies, were left on the PB ballot.

Perhaps not coincidentally, turnout in the 5th Ward PB election was relatively low, with only about 100 voters. “As word spreads, we look forward to more people taking part in next year’s Participatory Budgeting process,” said 5th Ward Chief of Staff Kimberl Webb in a statement. The winning three projects are an urban garden, street lamp improvements, and new lighting in Metra viaducts.

SherMon Plaza proposal FINAL 2-11-13
Proposed design of SherMon Plaza, which won funding in the 46th Ward.

In John Arena’s 45th Ward, on the Far Northwest Side, several bike projects did make it on the ballot, including bike lanes on Lawrence and Milwaukee, and on-street bike parking corrals, although they weren’t among the winning five projects. However, voters did support spending $125,000 to install a new pedestrian crossing light at the Jefferson Park Transit Center, which will also improve access for CTA buses. Over 650 people voted; winning proposals also included viaduct remediation and pigeon abatement, an artificial turf playing field for a local school, viaduct lighting and a community garden.

Residents of James Cappleman’s 46th ward, on the north lakefront, voted for some truly groundbreaking transportation proposals. The SherMon Plaza project will spend $79,000 on connecting a traffic island at Sheridan/Montrose/Broadway to the “mainland” to create a new public space, something that has likely never been done in Chicago. The $142,000 Leland Greenway will be a traffic calmed bike boulevard leading from Clark to the lakefront, another first. The $270,000 Walkable 46 project will fund crosswalks, pedestrian countdown signals and traffic calming. $448,000 will be spent on building or refreshing bike lanes on several streets in the ward. The other winning proposals were for security cameras in Sheridan Park and a left-turn signal at Sheridan/Irving Park. 390 residents voted in the election.

Arline Welty, a facilitator with the 46th Ward’s streets and cycling infrastructure committee, said she’s thrilled with the outcome. “Everything we wanted got completely funded,” she said. “It’s exciting that walking and biking improvements are the number-one priority in the ward, and we’re going to be able to deliver them.”

  • Anonymous

    every time I see that shermon plaza I think it’s pointless. It’s adjacent to a parking lot! who is going to go sit there in the between streets and a parking lot?

  • By removing this part of the road, it can actually improve the conditions for bicycling and walking. For starters, it will reduce the number of crossings one will have to make, and reduce the wait time (because two signal phases will no longer be there). It should reduce the wait time for drivers and bus passengers as well, because of the phase removal.

    A crosswalk could be built across Sheridan connecting the excess-roadway-converted-to-plaza at a perpendicular angle instead of the acute (or obtuse, depending on which direction you’re crossing) angle that’s there now (and which is longer than a perpendicular crossing).

  • Maybe once it’s been there a few years the property owner will redevelop to put not-a-parking-lot next to it. :->

  • m.

    It’d be great if it works this way! Many people in the neighborhood don’t want a parking lot there. The plaza will need to be developed further, but it starts the conversation and squarely points the direction that people want public money to support. So often planning in Uptown hasn’t been in keeping with its transit-and pedestrian-oriented past or reflective of the fact that 40% of locals don’t use private cars (and many more rarely use theirs). Pretty much everyone agrees that Uptown has way too many parking lots and one-story car-oriented business strips, so a real shocker recently has been the approval of the Sonic drive-in that’s planned for Wilson Ave so close to the huge public investment in Wilson Ave CTA station. In a sense, SherMon Plaza, regardless of what you think of the conception, says that residents want better urban planning.

  • m.

    The reduced crossing times will also improve conditions for those with disabilities. The area is traversed by many with limited mobility and children heading to the schools on Clarendon Avenue, both key constituent groups for other 46th Ward proposals like Walkable 46. Unfortunately Montrose Avenue traffic is about to get way worse because of the highrises planned for just two blocks east at Montrose & Clarendon—at last count there were over 600 parking places, a grocery store, fitness center, and 842 units. Fortunately Uptowner have great examples of public space like the enduring Sunnyside Mall ( to model into the future.

  • Given what I know of the area, I’d bet most of the car-centric tenants of those buildings (as opposed to the ones who have a car, but leave it in their parking space almost all the time) will go east on Montrose to Marine, and from there either cut to an arterial or hop straight on LSD. Narrow, walking-friendly streets are deliberately unfriendly to the kind of driver that wants to be travelling at a constant minimum 40MPH.

  • I really like Sunnyside Mall but I don’t like all the curbs that people on bikes have to jump up if they want to avoid the sidewalk curb ramps.


This Year’s 49th Ward PB Ballot Includes a Few Transit Projects

Each of Chicago’s 50 wards gets an annual $1.3 million in discretionary “menu” funding to spend on infrastructure projects each year. Usually the alderman decides how the money is spent and typically most of the money is used for traditional projects like street resurfacing, sidewalk repair, and streetlamp installation. However, the growing participatory budget movement, […]

Rogers Park Participatory Budgeting Ideas Include a North-South Greenway

Chicago aldermen traditionally use their $1.3 million in discretionary “menu” money for basic street, sidewalk and lighting improvements. However, this year a handful of wards are holding participatory budgeting elections. These often result in money being set aside for innovative transportation projects, and walking and biking infrastructure is a relative bargain. 49th Ward Alderman Joe […]