The Rant is Due: Yet Another Anti-Bike Screed From the Trib’s John McCarron

John McCarron

So far this has been a banner month for the Chicago Tribune when it comes to publishing tone-deaf commentary about bicycling.

On September 1, in response to four recent cycling deaths allegedly caused by reckless drivers, the Trib ran an editorial that put the onus on bike riders to be “particularly cautious” in order to prevent crashes. The piece even implied that cyclists are usually to blame for such tragedies: “Some may think they shouldn’t have to obey the same rules of the road as motorists.”

And last Thursday, for the third time in recent years, the paper published a flat-earth anti-bicycling rant by John McCarron, one of the Big Three of Chicago bike trolls, including Tribune commentator John Kass and DNAinfo columnist Mark Konkol. While this latest McCarron piece is truly a rambling, illogical diatribe, DePaul University actually retains the man as an adjunct lecturer in its school of communications.

It’s clear that bike-baiting op-eds like this are a strategy by the Tribune to garner pageviews, so maybe I shouldn’t send more clicks their way by dissecting the piece. But it’s hard for me to let the paper to publish this kind of garbage without providing a response, so let’s look at few of McCarron’s more absurd passages.

Of all the hoped-for alternatives to the family car — high-speed rail, shared cars, more compact towns, etc. — it’s those bike lanes that get me going. Not all bike lanes, mind you, but lanes like the [protected] one on Davis Street in downtown Evanston… God forbid you should make a right turn without first checking if a biker is pedaling up behind that row of parked cars.

Correct. Responsible driving means checking for bicyclists before making a right turn in order to avoid a “right-hook” crash, and in Chicago it’s the law. Section 9-16-020 of the Municipal Code of Chicago states: “When a motor vehicle and a bicycle are traveling in the same direction … the operator of the motor vehicle overtaking such bicycle traveling on the right side of the roadway shall not turn to the right in front of the bicycle… until such vehicle has overtaken and is safely clear of the bicycle.” Drivers who made right turns without first checking for bicyclists recently caused the deaths of cyclists Virginia Murray and Lisa Kuivinen.

Even on protected bike lane streets, including Davis, it doesn’t take much effort for drivers to avoid running someone over while making a right turn. Parking spaces are removed near intersections to ensure that motorists can easily see bike riders approaching on their right.

Screen Shot 2016-09-10 at 3.20.53 PM
Because parking is banned near intersections along the Davis protected bike lane, it’s actually quite easy to avoid killing someone with your car while making a right turn. Image: Google Street View

Next, for the second time in about a week, the Tribune promotes the myth that people biking are significantly less law-abiding that those driving. “Arrogance… lets cyclists tell themselves they are not bound by the same rules of the road that govern those of us behind the wheel,” McCarron writes. “So they glide through stoplights and signs.”

Right, because Chicago drivers – piloting multi-ton vehicles that can easily kill people – can always be trusted to obey stop signs and traffic signals. And then McCarron trots out this beloved “bikelash” warhorse:

They are rarely ticketed for these behaviors because they have no operator’s license, no vehicle registration, no practical way, really, for the police to process them into the judicial/enforcement system. Which also means they don’t pay for much. No gas tax. No fees. Theirs is pretty much a free ride.

Yep, there’s no practical way for the police to enforce traffic laws on bike riders, except for pulling them over, taking their ID, and issuing them a citation that, if the offender fails to show up for the Traffic Court hearing, will result in an arrest warrant.

And I think most Streetsblog readers are pretty bored with debunking the fallacy that cyclists are freeloading on our road system because they don’t burn gasoline. But in a nutshell, bike riders – who put little wear-and-tear on streets – do help pay for the transportation network via sales, income, and property taxes. Meanwhile gas tax and user fees don’t even come close to paying the cost of highway construction and maintenance, which means people who don’t drive are subsidizing roads they rarely travel on.

For an elegant and hilarious takedown of McCarron and his ilk, check out Luke Seeman’s Mad Lib-style template for “How to Write an Anti-Bike Commentary—Without the Nuisance of Actual Thought” in Chicago Magazine.

  • Jacob Wilson

    The Tribune has really engaged in a new level of negligence by fueling bicycle hate with it’s old, suburban readers just to get clicks. These two recent articles only fuel the road rage of drivers when confronting bicycles and will almost certainly lead to real harm if not death and the tribune knows it. Totally irresponsible and unethical.

  • Write a generic article that lists and refutes all the bogus anti-bike propaganda talking point “rant screeds.” Assign numbers to each item on the list. Edit the article as necessary over time. Include a permanent link in your right-hand column.

    Then any time an author or commenter needs to address these bogus assertions they can just cite the article and list number.

    The permanence of the list and its easy to find location will serve to illustrate just how tired and boring and repetitive these screeds are. It might even make some of these article easier to write. At the very least one can cut and paste entire list items directly into a comment or article if one wants more than just a hot-linked number.

    So an quick short article about the latest waste of pixel energy by McCarron might go like this:

    Latest McCarron
    http://www.Trib etc [but no hot link]

    32. 16. 5. 17.

  • That is a good time-saving idea!

  • Last Straw

    Time to cancel my subscription to the Trib

  • johnaustingreenfield

    If that wasn’t enough, they just axed media reporter Robert Feder.

  • Three Green Kashira

    after years of biking in chicago on random weekends & occasional fair-weather weekdays i finally had my first verbal encounter with a driver yesterday. i obviously have no way of knowing if her opinions were recently assisted by McCarron, but the first thing she said to me from her car was “There’s no bike lane on this street”, implying I shouldn’t be there. The rest of the discussion was irrelevant & peaceful (i told her i was still allowed to be there, she said please don’t hit my car, i told her not to hit me because it would kill me).

  • Shawn Mangan

    That “editorial” was pretty weak, but I’d have to give the Trib credit for the article they posted yesterday about construction on Milwaukee Ave and the issues its causing.

  • These comments have been around forever. I’ll never forget the time I was riding my bike north on Dearborn in the Loop years ago, before the Dearborn protected bike lane was installed. I was riding on the right side and as close to the parked cars as possible, when a driver in a car pulled up to a red light and started screaming through her open window at me to “Get in one of those bike lanes!” I really wanted to scream back that there was no bike lane on Dearborn or any other street in the Loop at that time; otherwise, I would very happily be riding in it. But, she had three little kids in the car who were looking at me with huge eyes, so I just waved at them and smiled, and moved ahead when I had the green. So many opportunities to practice zen skills when riding bikes in the city! :

  • Mimihaha

    I didn’t think anyone ever read the Trib anymore. I see no reason to do so.

  • Carter O’Brien

    I actually canceled mine yesterday.

  • johnaustingreenfield

    Yeah, Mary Wisniewski’s piece on construction was good and her bike reporting is usually pretty solid.

  • tooter turtle

    Suburban Republican rag…

  • tooter turtle

    What a bitch! But unfortunately such are common.


Today’s Headlines for Friday, September 9

958-Foot-Tall Tower Proposed Alongside Union Station (Curbed) CDOT Releases a User’s Guide to Address the Argyle Learning Curve (Curbed) The Tribune Runs Yet Another Flat-Earth Anti-Bike Rant by John McCarron Metra Is Having 41 Locomotives Rebuilt — First One Is Back in Service (Railway Gazette) Have Your Say on Plans for Uptown’s “Inner Coastal Zone” at […]

Today’s Headlines

CPS Finally Releases “Safe Passages” Routes for School Students (Sun-Times) Editorial: “[LSD’s] Primary Job is to Move Traffic.” No, It’s to Move People. (Sun-Times) Leader of Ashland NIMBYs at Wednesday Meeting: “We’re Not Anti-BRT” (Patch) Romanelli Pushes for Bringing Back Turns for Trucks Under Morgan Station (Gazette) Driver Kills Man on Roller Skates in Lombard […]

Today’s Headlines for Tuesday, July 26

UIC’s Urban Transportation Institute Releases Report on How IDOT Can Better Engage Public One Person Killed in Multi-Vehicle Crash on Stevenson That Resulted in Truck Fire (DNA) CTA Bus Driver Cited After Striking Mother & 3 Small Children, No Major Injuries (ABC) A Look at Illinois’ Special Purpose Districts (MPC) Whole Foods Discusses Why They […]

Today’s Headlines for Monday, March 7

CDOT Moves to Eliminate Dangerous Slip Lane at Grace/Halsted, Drivers Freak Out ( Curb Your Enthusiasm: The Tribune Looks at the Trend Towards Concrete-Protected Bike Lanes John McCarron: We Should Have Done a Downtown Circulator Bus Instead of Loop Link (Tribune) Henry English, Head of Black United Fund, Dead Following Car Crash (Sun-Times) Hit-and-Run Driver […]