On Broadway: A Preview of Chicago’s Next Protected Bike Lane Street

17-c1d57bfaaa
Layout of the protected lanes between Montrose and Wilson.

Uptown is one of Chicago’s few bike-friendly neighborhoods that doesn’t have any conventional bike lanes, let alone buffered or protected lanes, but that will change by the end of the year with an upcoming Chicago Department of Transportation project.

Broadway between Montrose and Foster will get protected bike lanes for two blocks from Montrose to Wilson, and buffered bike lanes from Wilson to Foster. This section of Broadway is designated as a crosstown bike route in CDOT’s Streets for Cycling 2020 Plan. The southern stretch will be one of the few PBL streets in town that also features plenty of pedestrian-oriented retail – hopefully this combination will become more common in the future.

19-d61a0899db
Layout of the buffered bike lanes between Wilson and Foster.

In addition to the new bike lanes, the entire 1.05-mile section will undergo a road diet, transforming the wide, four-lane street into two through lanes and a center turn lane. 16 existing metered parking spaces will be eliminated to improve sight lines at intersections. In compliance with the city’s parking contract, 12 new metered spots will be created elsewhere on Broadway, and the other four will be added on nearby streets within the 46th Ward.

The case for the road diet is strong. On average, Broadway carries 11,000 to 13,000 vehicles daily. Even though the new configuration reduces the number of travel lanes, it can accommodate as many as 20,000 car trips per day, according to CDOT. The new center turn lane will reduce traffic back-ups and swerving caused by left-turning motorists.

10583897195_f46625336d_z
Residents check out plans for the Broadway lanes at Wednesday's meeting at the 46th Ward office. Photo: Shaun Jacobsen

Even without bike lanes, recent CDOT bike counts at Broadway at Wilson recorded over 150 cyclists during a 4-hour period. The proximity of this section of Broadway to four Red Line stations, several bus lines, and many retailers also generates plenty of foot traffic. With the road diet, pedestrians will have fewer lanes of moving car traffic to cross, and there will be new, high-visibility zebra-striped crosswalks.

The plan resembles most other protected bike lane projects CDOT has implemented, which have a few shortcomings, mainly due to budget limitations. At the meeting, I suggested that leading pedestrian interval walk signals should be implemented if possible, and that cyclists be given legal permission to use the walk signal as their green light so as to make themselves visible to turning drivers. If this isn’t feasible for the Broadway, LPIs would be a useful addition to future projects.

10584164504_c0593e35f1_z
A mixing-zone bus stop is visible in this street plan for Broadway/Lawrence.

Bus stops on Broadway will be located in “mixing zones” with cyclists. Therefore, when buses stop to load and unload passengers, cyclists will have to ride to the left of the bus, or wait behind it. On PBLs like the one on Dearborn, green paint has been added at conflict points to alert drivers to the presence of the bike lanes but, due to fiscal restraints, there are no plans for this on Broadway.

Finally, there will be no dedicated left turn facilities for bicyclists. It’s up to cyclists to determine how to best execute a left turn from the protected lane. Dearborn features left-turn boxes for bikes.

10584218175_3b3983808c_z
Left-turn box at Dearborn and Lake. Photo: Shaun Jacobsen

At the meeting, a CDOT staffer said feedback from community members on the project has been mostly positive. One attendee stated that he was not anti-bike, but asked why the city is “catering to cyclists while diminishing car capacity,” noting that while Chicago drivers need to buy an annual city registration sticker, cyclists don’t have to pay an analogous fee. However, Broadway currently has excess car capacity, which encourages speeding. After the reconfiguration it will still have more than enough capacity, but traffic will be calmed.

The $200,000 project is an investment in the community. Not only do calmer streets with accommodations for all users have the potential to create more vibrant neighborhoods, they also reduce the rate of crashes and injuries. For example, since a protected bike lane was installed on 9th Avenue in Manhattan, the street has seen a 56-percent reduction in injuries to all street users.

10556243704_61d93efc5a_z
Currently Broadway has too much capacity, which encourages speeding. Photo: Shaun Jacobsen

Between 2006 and 2010, there were 909 crashes in the Broadway project area, 113 of which resulted in injury. On average, each injury crash costs the city $53,000, so a safer street will lead to significant savings for taxpayers.

The new bike infrastructure will link to several existing and future bikeways. The Leland Greenway, a project elected by residents during last year’s 46th Ward participatory budgeting process, will be installed from Clark to Clarendon, intersecting with this stretch of Broadway.

The northern terminus of the Broadway bike lanes is located just west of Winthrop, a southbound recommended route on the city’s bike map, and Kenmore, a northbound recommended route. However, the connection from Broadway to these streets via Foster is not currently signed, and no signs are planned. A block north of Foster, Berwyn is a recommended westbound route from Broadway.


View Uptown bikeways in a larger map

Buffered section of Broadway (blue), protected section (green), Leland Greenway route (orange), sharrow streets (magenta), and recommended routes (yellow)

At the southern terminus of the new bike lanes, the large and confusing Broadway/Montrose/Sheridan intersection may be intimidating to inexperienced cyclists, and there won’t be any wayfinding signs to guide them onto other bike-friendly streets. However, the intersection is slated to be reconfigured in the future to be safer and more inviting. The leg of Sheridan through the intersection will be closed to create a new pedestrian space called SherMon Plaza, another project selected in the participatory budgeting process.

There is currently no plan to extend the Broadway bike lanes southeast .8 miles to connect with existing conventional bike lanes on Halsted. In the meantime, a bike-friendly way to make the connection is to ride two blocks east on Montrose to Clarendon, which has sharrows and light traffic – only 4,700 cars daily. From there one can pedal a half mile south to the Halsted lanes.

The Broadway is being bankrolled with $155,000 in menu money from the 46th ward, and $45,000 in CDOT funds. Next week, the transportation department will do patch resurfacing, and striping will begin shortly afterwards, provided that the weather is conducive. At 50 degrees pavement is still warm enough for laying thermoplastic paint, but markings applied at lower temperatures soon peel off the asphalt. CDOT learned that lesson the hard way after bikeways installed last year on Desplaines and Division in too-cold weather quickly degraded.

  • Anonymous

    Shaun, great article.
    Both Kenmore and Winthrop go south to Leland. I much prefer Leland over Fosteer as an east-west connector.

  • Thanks Duppie. Some people did say they’d prefer to hop on Kenmore/Winthrop south of Foster since Foster is a busy street. Hopefully with the Leland greenway the connection will be obvious.

  • I wonder why the bus stops are still near-side, instead of the now standard far-side?

  • The 78 stops at Sunnyside are far-side stops. No word on the others.

  • Joseph Musco

    Great report Shaun. This is a positive project! I don’t know what brand of thermoplastic is being used but here are some details on a popular brand.


    From 3M’s Thermoplastic Pavement Marking guidelines:

    Temperature – Application of 3M all weather thermoplastic System is recommended at the following temperatures:

    Screed or Extrusion application: Air and pavement 50º F (10º C) and rising.

    Spray application: Air and pavement 55º F (13º C) and rising.

    Note: Wind (wind chill) can cause quicker cooling. Application is not recommended at wind chill less than 45º F (7º C). Also be aware that pavement temperature for a shaded area can be lower.

    Moisture – Road surfaces must be clean and dry
    – – –

    The Weather Channel lists average mean temps for 11/3 as 48 degrees, 45 degrees on 11/8, 43 degrees on 11/12. I hope CDOT checks the weather before proceeding outside of the recommended conditions for application. Repeating the same mistakes as last season would not be good for anyone.

  • Marven Norman

    Looks good, but why do bicycle left turns have to be a problem? Install bicycle signals that are not phased with car signals. Bikes can then go any direction they please/need to without worry since no cars should be in the intersection.

  • FGFM

    Cappleman’s Caucasian Cavalcade!

  • Jeff Wegerson

    The other shoe here is Broadway north of Foster to Devon. The goal I believe is to replace or augment the Winthrop/Kenmore Bike corridors with the Broadway lanes all the way to Devon. One holdup apparently is the fact that Broadway north of Foster is a state road.

  • Anonymous

    There is no money in the budget for bicycle-specific signals, nor should there be. There will be a center turn lane all the way from from Montrose to Foster. So bicyclists (and cars) no longer have to wait in the through-lane. Should make it safer for all involved.

  • Anonymous

    North of Foster, the department of Housing and Economic Development is conducting a study about what needs to be done with that corridor. The results should become available Q1 next year. Any bike lane on Broadway north of Foster is at least a few years way, according to CDOT.

    In the short-term, the plan is to extend the Kenmore and Winthrop bike route south to Foster. I personally find that silly. they both are already excellent low-traffic streets to ride on.

    IDOT only manages the one block north of Foster to Berwyn. The rest is city managed. IDOT is not against buffered lanes, which would be likely to be the lane of choice there.

  • Anonymous

    And with the buffered lanes extending north, I think that it will become safer to ride on Broadway to Argyle, and take Argyle east to Winthrop/Kenmore or west to Andersonville. This is a stretch of Broadway I currently avoid.

  • Tyler

    Glad to hear re-configuring Sheridan/Montrose/Broadway is also in the cards – I hate that intersection as both a pedestrian and motorist, and I haven’t even biked through it!

  • Mishellie

    Why shouldn’t there be? Also… bicyclists will still have to cross the traffic lane to the center. Now, you and I might be ok with making two quick lane changes at an intersection… but average joe will not be. Hell, most of the time I’m still making box lefts… more waiting, but less lane changes, and that’s ok with me.

  • Anonymous

    Because it would more than double the cost of the project, making it a lot less likely that this project would happen at all.

  • Experienced bike riders usually know how to make a safer two-point left turn. It’s not that hard, I do it on Broadway now. I wouldn’t wait in the center-turn lane to do it. But I do think it would be nice to have an indication of how to turn left in two moves safely – many do not know how.

  • Marven Norman

    The current traffic count is 11k cars/day, with capacity for 20k. That’s far too high to expect someone to mingle their way over to the center lane to make a turn. This is confirmed by the mention that specific cycle facilities for lefts won’t be included as part of the initial project. If traffic counts are truly low enough, no facility would be necessary, including the lanes themselves. The whole street would just be a bicycle boulevard.

    So if money isn’t available currently, then every effort possible should be made to secure some ASAP. And make it for signals, not just bike boxes. That way, the danger of right hooks can be removed as well by phasing vehicular rights separate from bicycle greens.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Mix of Protected and Buffered Bike Lanes Slated for Busy Broadway

|
The Chicago Department of Transportation will redesign Broadway between Montrose and Foster, a mile-long stretch that’s currently a very car-centric four- to five-lane road. The street is so inhospitable that one resident at a public meeting Wednesday night said she doesn’t drive, walk, or bike on it. The agency failed to make a “complete street” […]

Solving The Problem of Snow Being Pushed Into Protected Lanes

|
In general, protected bike lanes are great for encouraging “interested-but-concerned” folks to try urban cycling. However, as I discussed last week, when the lanes aren’t maintained well during the winter, they can actually make cycling more difficult. And when snow- or ice-filled PBLs force bike riders to share narrow travel lanes with motorists, that decreases […]

Chicago Building Four Miles of Protected Bike Lanes This Year

|
The City of Chicago announced a new slate of bikeway projects today, outlining about 15 miles of new buffered bike lanes and a little more than four miles of protected lanes to be built in 2014. Under the plan for this year, protected bikeway construction in Chicago would continue to outpace every other American city except […]

Eyes on the Street: New Bikeways on State Street and Archer Avenue

|
To borrow from a famous song, on State Street, that great street, I just gotta say, they’ve done something they haven’t done yet on (Chicago’s) Broadway. They’ve installed nearly perfect Windy City-style protected bike lanes. The one-mile bikeway on State from 18th Street to 26th Street, features silky-smooth new asphalt, a four-to-three conversion road diet, […]