Justice for South Side Dad Who Was Right-Hooked in 31st Street Protected Lane

Andrew Berg and his children. Photo courtesy of Berg
Andrew Berg and his children. Photo courtesy of Berg

There’s some good news in the case of Andrew Berg, a South Side father who was struck and injured by a right-turning driver while bicycling in the 31st Street protected bike lane last May. After suing the driver and winning the case in arbitration, yesterday he received a settlement to cover his hospital bills, pain and suffering, and damage to his cycle.

At the time of the crash Berg was riding his “long-tail” cargo bike from his job at the University of Chicago to his home in McKinley Park in the rain, pedaling west in the 31st Street protected lane with a green light. Westbound driver Amy Kudlov made a right turn onto Indiana Avenue, striking him in a “mixing zone” just east of the intersection, where drivers are supposed to yield to bike traffic while merging across the bike lane. Berg was knocked to the pavement suffering abrasions to the right side of his body, including his elbow, knee, and ankle. He sustained permanent scarring on his elbow.

Although visibility was poor, Berg says he had two bright lights on in the front of his bike and three in the back, so he should have been easy to spot, but responding police officers didn’t ticket Kudlov.

The driver gave the cyclist her name and telephone number and promised to send him her insurance info that evening. But Berg says Kudlov never responded to repeated calls and text messages, so he filed a small claims case against her, which eventually got moved to an arbitration hearing at the request of the driver’s attorney.

According to Berg, he had initially had trouble finding legal representation because there wasn’t the potential for a large settlement. But he says that after Streetsblog Chicago ran a post about the crash, he sent the piece to the bike-focused firm Keating Law Offices (a Streetsblog sponsor), and the firm agreed to take on the case. “They said they didn’t want to leave a cyclist behind and were trying to get justice,” he says. “I’m thankful to everyone in the bike community and the attorneys for supporting me.”

31st and Indiana, where where Kudlov struck him in the “mixing zone.” Photo: Andrew Berg
31st and Indiana, where where Kudlov struck him in the “mixing zone.” Photo: Andrew Berg

Berg says a highlight of the January 18 arbitration hearing was when Kudlov’s attorney objected to Berg’s explanation of the bike-and-chevron symbol in the mixing zone where the driver struck him. The cyclist cited the definition of “Marked Shared Lanes” on the city of Chicago’s bike map as the source for his knowledge, noting that, unlike bike lanes, motorists are allowed to drive in this portion of the roadway, but they must yield to cyclists. The arbitrator declared his testimony to be “expert” and overruled the objection.

The cyclist says that two other factors that worked in his favor were that Kudlov’s testimony was inconsistent about whether she was in the through lane or the turn lane when she entered the intersection, and she acknowledged that she saw a light in her sideview mirror prior to the crash. “My assumption is she saw one or both of my headlights, and one was a 350-lumen flashing light, but she still didn’t check her blind spot before turning, and that’s how she hit me.”

Berg says the crash hasn’t deterred him from riding his bike. “I’m actually more commited than ever to promoting safe cycling and bike infrastructure.” His family recently moved to Hyde Park and he taught his five-year-old daughter to bike last week, so he’s looking into re-launching Hyde Park’s Kidical Mass child-friendly bike ride. He also has a three-year-old son.

“In the grand scheme of things, I’m glad the crash wasn’t more serious,” Berg says. “My kids weren’t with me [on the back of the cargo bike]. They could have been killed.”

Berg added that he took his children to the “ghost bike” installation ceremony for fallen cyclist Anastasia Kondrasheva, 23, who was fatally struck by a right-turning truck driver at Addision and Damen last fall. “So we’re educating our children about how much fun it is to ride a bike, but also the responsibilities and dangers,” he said.

  • Anne A

    I’m glad that he was able to get a settlement, and that he’s still riding and teaching his children.

    That’s a tricky spot. I’ve had conflicts with drivers there on more than one occasion. I listen and watch my mirror carefully when I’m approaching that intersection.

  • wesaymwah

    Odd that the driver admitted she’d seen a light in her side mirror, but what amazes me is that she appeared to be unaware that she had just passed him. Sounds like zero awareness to me, and should have been cited.

  • Joe D

    I have always thought that for the most part the only justice for a cyclist hit by a car is through a negotiated settlement as the courts and law enforcement favor drivers. They probably think that bicyclists are just begging for it riding on the roads.

  • ShatteredGlass00

    Motorists mostly and rightfully focus on what’s directly in front of them in their path and naturally filter out irrelevant data like “out of the way” cyclists in “protected” bike lanes.

    Once a motorist has passed a cyclist the only way they can crash is if the cyclist begins to pass the motorist on the right as the motorist slows and turns.

    Cyclists should never let their front wheel pass the rear bumper of a car on their left that can and may turn right.

  • Sa Reid

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

CDOT Unveils Bold Vision for Milwaukee Bike Lanes; Drivers Grouse

|
At last night’s community meeting at Intuit arts center, the Chicago Department of Transportation discussed its vision for innovative bike lanes on Milwaukee between Kinzie and Elston. The plan, which is actually much more ambitious than what was outlined on the CDOT website prior to the meeting, involves removing about half of the car-parking spaces […]

Eyes on the Street: New Protected Bike Lanes on Canal Street

|
New Bikeways Week rolls on with a look at the new protected bike lanes on Canal Street between Harrison Street and Roosevelt Road. Several recently constructed Chicago bikeways, such as the lanes on Milwaukee Avenue between Kinzie Street and Elston Avenue, are largely made up of buffered lanes, sometimes with flexible posts that discourage, but […]

City Begins Work on Next 50 Miles of Bikeways, Funds Bikes N’ Roses

|
Today at a ribbon cutting for curb-protected bike lanes on 31st Street by the Illinois Institute of Technology, Mayor Emanuel and transportation commissioner Rebekah Scheinfeld elaborated on the city’s previously announced plan to build 50 more miles of bikeways by 2019. This represents a slower pace of installation than the city’s previous achievement of installing […]