America’s “New” Rail Systems Are Showing Their Age

Rail systems like BART and WMATA -- that were built in the 70s and 80s -- are beginning to show their age. Chart via <a href="https://twitter.com/christofspieler/status/716946772854059008" target="_blank">Christof Spieler/Twitter</a>

Rail systems built 40 years ago like BART and DC Metro have serious maintenance needs. Click to enlarge. Chart via Christof Spieler/Twitter

What should we make of the recent headline-grabbing service disruptions at Washington Metro and BART? This chart from Houston transit advocate Christof Spieler offers some important perspective.

These transit systems are reaching the age where maintenance needs are increasingly urgent. Alex Block at City Block writes:

BART, the snake digesting the mouse: Until seeing the data presented this way, I never appreciated how much of the BART system (navy blue on the chart) was built in quick succession in the early 1970s. The system didn’t add any route miles until the first phases of the San Mateo-SFO Airport extension came online starting in 1995. Contrast that to the history of WMATA (gray bars on the chart) regularly opening smaller system segments over a span of 20 years. MARTA also expanded by adding segments over the course of two decades.

The implication for maintenance is that BART is kinda like a snake digesting a meal — the bulge of maintenance needs/life cycle costs now coming due. WMATA has a similar length of track to maintain, but won’t have to deal with such a large portion of the system reaching mid-life at the same time.

Block points out that the chart also highlights the shrinking federal support for grade-separated urban rail systems:

End of Federal (Capital) Role: It’s hard to overlook the long-term trend as well — cities aren’t opening new third-rail, fully grade-separated transit systems anymore. There are only seven of these systems, most of which received substantial capital funding from the predecessor to the Federal Transit Administration, the Urban Mass Transit Administration; and there have only been a handful of expansions of these systems (absent federal funding) since 2004. Of those recent expansions, two are airport connectors (Miami and Oakland – and the other is WMATA’s first phase of the Silver Line, eventually destined to reach Dulles International Airport).

Limited federal funding, rising costs, and limited flexibility of fully grade-separated systems meant that capital spending shifted away from subways and towards light rail systems.  Even high capacity transit projects (such as Seattle’s light rail system) with substantial grade separation have opted for the flexibility of a light rail platform. Subway system expansion in the US is limited to regions locked into that technology.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Transport Providence makes the case for replacing the 6/10 Connector with a surface boulevard instead of an underground highway. Tim Kovach says a parking tax could be a smart answer to Cleveland’s transit funding crisis. And Mobilizing the Region points out a glaring flaw in how the Federal Highway Administration markets its National Household Travel Survey.

  • david vartanoff

    BART and WMATA were the DOD vendor “Buck Rogers”not the dirty subway systems built to reassure suburban whites that they could use transit to their office jobs in the CBD without having much interaction with Michael Harrington’s Other America. In the WMATA case, they brag about highest farebox recovery but have clearly skimped on maintenance from the get go. The widely circulated picture of the seriously damaged power cable is evidence of incompetent or faked inspections. If the new GM is serious there should be a parade of those involved leaving the property.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

D.C. Metro Shutdown Should Be a Wakeup Call: Spend Smart on Transit

|
Today’s emergency 24-hour shutdown of the D.C. Metro system is a transit embarrassment of epic proportions. The shutdown follows an electrical fire in a subway tunnel Monday, and will allow for system-wide safety inspections. Metro has been under federal control following a smoke inhalation death caused by a similar problem last year. David Alpert at Greater Greater Washington wonders how the region’s […]
STREETSBLOG USA

The Looming Transit Breakdown That Threatens America’s Economy

|
While federal transit funding stagnates, the nation’s largest rail and bus systems have been delaying critical maintenance projects. Without sustained efforts to fix infrastructure and vehicles, the effects of deteriorating service in big American cities could ripple across the national economy, according to a new report from the Regional Plan Association [PDF]. RPA focuses on ten of the nation’s largest transit agencies […]
STREETSBLOG USA

A Year After Houston’s Bus Network Redesign, Ridership Is Up

|
After years of declining bus ridership, last August Houston METRO overhauled service patterns around the city, updating the bus network for the first time since the 1970s. Practically overnight, Houston’s network changed from a hub-and-spoke model to a more grid-like system designed to expand access to frequent service to more of the city. Night and weekend service dramatically […]