They Didn’t F— It Up This Time: Mumford & Sons Gig Was a Car-Free Success

Mumford_&_Sons_in_Teatro_Romano_Verona_2012
Mumford & Sons. Photo: Wikipedia

Quasi-Celtic, sensitive-guy drinking songs are not everyone’s cup of tea. However, I think most Uptown residents will agree that making last Friday’s massive Mumford & Sons concert at Montrose Beach Harbor a zero-car parking event was a clever strategy. Thanks to that enlightened approach, plus beefed-up sustainable transportation options, the park was able to accommodate some 35,000 attendees with minimal traffic congestion in the neighborhood.

“The car-free part worked out really well,” said Tressa Feher, chief of staff for 46th Ward Alderman James Cappleman. “We didn’t see a lot of cars coming to and from the event, and there was pretty steady traffic flow in the neighborhood and on Lake Shore Drive.” She added that her office received few complaints about car congestion afterwards.

Cappleman, various city departments, and promoter Jam Productions agreed in advance that a zero-parking concert was the way to go, according to Feher. Although there are hundreds of curbside parking spaces and two large parking lots near the beach, it was decided that Montrose, Wilson, and Lawrence avenues would be closed to drivers east of LSD. Temporary No Parking signs were also posted on some neighborhood streets.

“Since this is a dense neighborhood with a lot of transit access, and the beach is right by the Lakefront Trail, the goal was to get everyone into the area with as few cars as possible,” Feher said. “In addition to reducing traffic, that helps local businesses. People are more likely to spend money in the neighborhood because they can’t just get in their cars and drive away.”

Screen Shot 2015-06-23 at 12.31.26 PM
Screenshot from the Jam website. When you click on the parking icon, you are advised not to drive to the concert.

Ticket holders were given plenty of advance warning that driving to hear the English crooners would be a fool’s errand. “THERE IS NO PARKING PROVIDED FOR THIS EVENT,” stated the Jam Productions website. “It is highly recommended to ride your bike or a Divvy to the concert site to avoid traffic. Please use all available public transportation systems as the alternative to driving.” The site provided detailed advice on how to get to the show without a car.

Jam operations manager David Carlucci underscored this message at a recent community meeting, DNAinfo reported. “Please do not drive to Montrose Beach Harbor,” he told attendees. Of course, some people missed the memo. The city towed 36 automobiles whose drivers disregarded the No Parking signs, according to DNA.

In addition to the “stick” of zero car parking, the “carrot” of enhanced sustainable transportation options encouraged fans to leave their autos at home. Since the park is only a 15-minute walk east from the Wilson ‘L’ station, the CTA added additional Red Line runs. They also increased the number of buses on the #78 Montrose, #81 Lawrence, and #146 Inner Drive/ Michigan Express routes. Metra added additional service as well.

17331839232_c809885f2d_o
Tents in the Wilson viaduct. Last time I passed by, tents lined the entire passage. Photo: Curtis Locke

The Wilson Avenue viaduct under LSD is normally filled with tents belonging to homeless people, and city workers cleared out this encampment before the concert. In These Times slammed this decision with the headline, “The City of Chicago Used a Mumford & Sons Concert To Displace Homeless People.” This isn’t the first time Cappleman has been accused of insensitivity to the plight of Uptown’s homeless, but in this case there may have been no alternative.

The tents occupied almost half the width of the viaduct, so it would have been difficult to squeeze the thousands of pedestrians coming from the train through the underpass without removing the encampment. “What we heard from the police department and [the Office of Emergency Management and Communications] is that they were worried about the number of people using the viaduct, and they wanted to make sure it was safe for everybody,” Feher said.

Taxi and car-share stands were set up outside the park, and special accommodations were made for Divvy bike-share users as well. At one point in the evening the Montrose Harbor docking station temporarily stopped accepting bikes due to cell interference, general manger Elliot Greenberger told me. However, Divvy staffers were on hand to corral the cycles. All told, 300 bikes arrived at the show that night, making the station the busiest in the city.

IMG_0007
Chainlinkers at the bike valet. Yasmeen Schuller is at the far right. Photo: Amy McCrackin

For those who rode their own bicycles to the show, Jam provided a free bike valet with space for 4,000 cycles, operated by members of The Chainlink, a local social networking site for bicyclists. I stopped by to help out near the end of the concert. When I arrived, I saw plenty of bikes locked to fences and trees closer to the Lakefront Trail, but it was difficult to find the valet area, which was located far from the path on the east side of the concert area.

Several traffic management aides and concert employees I asked had no idea where the corral was located. Due to the location, plus the chilly temperatures, only about 500 Mumford fans used the corral. “We had fewer bikes than anticipated,” Chainlink owner Yasmeen Schuller told me. “But, overall, I am very pleased because people checking their bikes in had a good experience and we returned their bikes quickly.”

Although there’s a Beach Boys and Kool and the Gang concert at the harbor this Friday, it’s only expected to draw about 10,000 people, according to Feher. “The parking will be normal and there are no additional transportation plans,” she said. “We’ve had a few other concerts there with 5,000-to-10,000 people, and no one in the neighborhood even knew there was a show going on.”

IMG_1922
A typical day at the beach at Montrose Harbor. Photo: John Greenfield

That may have been the case, but when I visited Montrose Beach last Sunday afternoon, business-as-usual meant that the park drives and nearby neighborhood streets were clogged with cars. The Mumford & Sons concert probably drew far more people than the number who were at the harbor that afternoon. However, on the night of the show, it was easier to get around than during a typical day at the beach.

It makes you wonder what Montrose Beach Harbor would be like if limited car parking – and excellent transit and bike access – was the rule, rather than the exception.

  • Hollywood (Osterman) beach has no parking, as you know. I always thought it was to keep the riff-raff out. Of course what would be great would be transit on lsd that stopped at all the over-passes.

  • Pat

    The one thing I noticed was that Divvy did not account for how all those bikes would ripple through their system. All docks in Lakeview/Lincoln Park area (Fullerton to Addison and LSD to Halsted) were completely full Friday night post-concert.

    After visiting 6 docks coming from Addison/Ashland (some with the elusive 1 spot that didn’t exist), I had to take mine home with me. Divvy was understanding, and reversed the charges. Definitely hard to foresee, and I trust Divvy will use this as a learning experience.

  • duppie

    Boy that concert was loud. Almost 2.5 miles away, we could follow the lyrics clearly.
    /grumpy-old-man-rant

  • tooch

    Not sure the “zero-car parking event” fits the bill as a “clever strategy”. I just don’t think, realistically, there is enough parking in the area to accommodate anything close to the expected concert attendance – Saturday/Sunday mornings with youth sports, dog beach visitors, bikers, runners, etc barely fit! The suggestions to utilize public transportation and/or taxi feels like it came more from lack of options.

    Regardless, glad the event took place and like another poster mentioned, it was actually nice to sit outside on my patio and listen to the concert 1.5 miles away!

  • If they didn’t choose a zero-car parking strategy, how many spaces do you think should have been available to concert attendees?

  • tooch

    i think their strategy of zero-car parking makes complete sense. in fact, it’s common sense for concerts of this size in this location. that’s why i don’t think of it as a “clever strategy”. it was noted in the piece that for smaller concerts, the current parking situation works well and us local residents hardly even know something is afoot (i can attest to this being the truth!) – so there’s a natural threshold of concert sizes that necessitate to shift from a “normal parking” situation to a “zero-car” situation.

  • Obesa Adipose

    For christs sake give them their due.

  • Matt F

    what? choosing to have a concert there implies “zero car strategy” not the other way around. the choice isn’t to have parking there or not — it’s to have a concert there or at a different venue.

  • what_eva

    Thanks for the update. I’m a little surprised the Park District shut the lots down rather than go for revenue.

    As for the 36 towed, I would guess that wasn’t concert goers that missed the message, but people who leave their cars in the park long term and didn’t hear about the signs. Not uncommon around the north side.

  • Lisa Curcio

    Yep, we could hear it in Belmont Harbor, too. Can someone please tell me the point of music so loud that it blasts your eardrums that far away? /grumpy-old woman-rant

  • If Mumford & Sons was too loud for you folks, perhaps it would be a good idea to go on vacation when the heavy metal band Manowar plays Montrose Harbor later this summer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manowar Just kidding.

  • Jeff H

    Dude, you got me excited for a second, I would LOVE to see Manowar live on the lakefront. But alas, it is not meant to be.

  • Yeah, I don’t think it would be a good idea to have the band that hold the Guinness World Record for volume play on the lakefront.

  • veronimama

    I used the bike valet and loved it. It was so quick, well run, and really efficient. My only (very tiny) complaint is that the fenders and brakes on both my boyfriend and my bike were bent/moved. I’m all for speed and efficiency, but not at the mercy of my bike. It wasn’t anything huge, and I’m well aware this was a free service. Still extremely happy with the whole deal.

  • Chris Chaten

    I was at the show. I was pleased at how reasonable the volume was. I’m getting old and have some sound lowering earplugs that I use at shows, not needed here. I think the issue is Chicago is flat, by a body of water. Sound travels, esp bass.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Developer Proposes Just What Lakeview Doesn’t Need: Tons of Parking

|
A new development threatens to degrade the pedestrian-oriented nature of one of Chicago’s most walkable neighborhoods by building excessive car parking at a mixed-use project close to transit. In Wrigleyville, M&R Development is proposing 148 houses, 169,000 square feet of retail space, a health club, and 493 parking spaces at Addison Avenue, Clark Street, and Sheffield […]

Today’s Headlines for Friday, June 19

|
50 Percent of Renters Along North Side Red Line Have No Car but Have a Parking Space (MPC) Developer Plans New Skyscrapers in South Loop with Driveways on Harrison Bike Lane Mumford & Sons Concert, With 5,000 Bike Valet Spaces, Rescheduled to Tonight (Tribune) Exec at LAZ Parking, Parking Meter Operators, Goes on Leave During FBI […]

New Pritzker Project Is Basically A Transit-Ignoring Development

|
As I’ve stated before, Colonel Jennifer Pritzker, a historic preservationist and an heir to the Pritzker family fortune, has used her wealth in creative ways to help revitalize the Rogers Park community. She deserves credit for restoring Frank Lloyd Wright’s Emil Bach House, as well as bringing the Mayne Stage music theater and other businesses […]

Does Montrose Beach Really Need So Much Car Parking?

|
In the wake of a melee at Montrose Beach last Sunday — the latest in a series of violent incidents — 46th Ward Alderman James Cappleman proposed an intriguing strategy for preventing violence: reduce the number of parking spots at the beach. On Sunday afternoon, a large group of people gathered at Montrose for an […]