Quinn, Rauner Should Get On Board With Region’s Performance Measures

The Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning’s lauded GO TO 2040 regional plan prioritizes transportation investments based on performance measures, rather than through arbitrary formulas or aggressive politicking. This ensures that the hundreds of millions of federal dollars that CMAP handles are spent on projects selected on need and merit, rather than just because someone important likes the idea – which, sadly, has typically been the case in metropolitan Chicago. Yet the two major parties’ candidates for Illinois governor showed only a passing familiarity with the concept when asked about it at a recent event.

Governor Pat Quinn and Bruce Rauner demonstrated their misunderstanding of performance measures at the Metropolitan Planning Council’s  annual luncheon last Thursday. This unfamiliarity was particularly surprising, since both campaigns had met with MPC to review the questions beforehand.

GO TO 2040, authored by CMAP and adopted by over 200 Chicagoland municipalities, establishes performance measures that evaluate major projects’ potential to increase transit use, reduce driving, and eliminate harmful smoke and soot. Currently, however, most of the state’s transportation funding for roads and bridges bypasses this system and is allocated by a formula: 45 percent of funds go to Chicagoland, even though this area has 65 percent of the state’s population and 70 percent of economic activity.

Moderator Craig Dellimore of WBBM asked each candidate, “To get more ‘bang for the buck,’ do you support using performance measures to select Illinois’ transportation investments – for instance, prioritizing new road or transit projects that measurably improve access to jobs, reduce air pollution and spark adjacent economic development?”

Even putting aside the candidates’ usual attempts to steer every question towards their own talking points, both candidates’ answers showed an incomplete understanding of what performance measures are.

MPC 2014 Annual Luncheon
Rauner says he supports performance measures. Photo: Tricia Scully/MPC

Rauner answered pretty directly, saying he “emphatically, strongly supports performance evaluation when we’re making these decisions,” and that he’d want to work with MPC to come up with the best way to do that. He added that there should be cost-benefit analyses “of our spending and regulations.”

He should already know that CMAP already does cost-benefit evaluations of each major project. MPC’s question was less about evaluating projects, but instead comparing projects to each other – and only funding the ones which better achieve the region’s goals.

Quinn has proudly subverted our region’s infrastructure performance measures to advance his own political aims. He injudiciously got Metra and Pace to side with road expansion interests, and vote to include the Illiana Tollway into the GO TO 2040 plan. That act heightened the already stiff competition for scarce transportation funds, and CMAP’s own staff said that Illiana was antithetical to the plan’s goal of focusing on already-developed areas.

MPC 2014 Annual Luncheon
Quinn also supports performance measures, except when they prevent pet projects. Photo: Tricia Scully/MPC

Quinn responded that he thinks performance measures are important — but then grabbed the chance to tout one of his administration’s accomplishments. A new highway bridge crossing the Mississippi River at St. Louis met “all performance requirements,” and that local African Americans accounted for 24 percent of the project’s workforce. I’m glad that Illinois built a bridge that meets engineering standards, and exceeded minority hiring requirements, but again, we should expect that new bridges should meet relevant safety standards and applicable laws. Those are baseline standards, not performance goals.

It’s time for each campaign to take a much closer look at GO TO 2040’s goals, which focus on building livable communities, with affordable and connected transportation opportunities, by reinvesting in the communities where most Illinoisans already live and work. Quinn’s own performance in respecting the plan has been dismal, and so far Rauner has scarcely mentioned it.


Seven Ways to Stop The Illiana Boondoggle

Two votes yesterday by a committee of the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning, Chicagoland’s federally-designated regional planning organization, have cemented CMAP’s approval of the sprawl-inducing, budget-busting Illiana Tollway. Since federal transportation dollars can only be spent on projects included in an adopted regional plan, this gives Governor Pat Quinn and the Illinois Department of Transportation the consent […]

Could Rauner Stop the Illiana Boondoggle? Sure. But Will He?

The Illiana Tollway, a joint proposal by the Illinois and Indiana departments of transportation to build a 47-mile highway through thinly populated farmland about 40 miles south of Chicago, rolled over another hurdle yesterday when the Federal Highway Administration approved the project’s environmental impact study. FHWA’s approval allows IDOT and InDOT to proceed with soliciting bids for […]

CMAP Plan Update Includes Sobering Look at Region’s Funding Shortfall

The Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning’s GO TO 2040 regional comprehensive plan has weathered some major ups and downs in its four-year lifespan. CMAP has received several awards for the plan, which required a huge effort on their part to reach out to local residents and overwrite decades of uncoordinated transportation “plans.” Last year, though, the […]

Rauner Authorizes More Illiana Spending to “Wind Down” Project

Governor Bruce Rauner signed a bill last week that authorizes spending $5.5 million more on the Illiana Tollway, a month after he announced he was suspending the project. The Illiana would have been a new highway a couple miles south of the existing Chicago metropolitan region that would have encouraged suburban sprawl. Tolls would have been […]

CMAP Seeks Its Own Dedicated Tax For Transit, Green Infrastructure

The Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning last week floated its own proposal to fix the region’s shortfall in transportation funding. It launched FUND 2040, a campaign calling upon the Illinois legislature to fund sustainable infrastructure through a quarter-cent sales tax across the Chicagoland region. CMAP says this increase would generate $300 million annually, which it […]