Narrowly Written Ordinance Makes It Difficult to Install Curbside Cafes

people spot 7
The people spot in front of Osteria Pizza Metro was open to the public, but it was often mistaken for a private sidewalk cafe. Photo: Latent Design

[The Chicago Reader recently launched a new weekly transportation column written by Streetsblog Chicago editor John Greenfield. This partnership allows Streetsblog to extend the reach of our livable streets advocacy. We syndicate a portion of the column on the day it comes out online; you can read the remainder on the Reader’s website or in print. The paper hits the streets on Thursdays.]

In the summer of 2014, two so-called people spots opened near the intersection of Diversey and Clark in east Lakeview. They were installed in the parking lanes in front of El Nuevo Mexicano restaurant, at 2914 N. Clark, and Osteria de Pizza Metro, 2863 N. Clark, for a total cost of $35,000, in an effort to revitalize a section of the street that suffered from narrow sidewalks and empty storefronts.

These on-the-street seating areas, also known as “parklets,” consisted of wooden platforms, tables, and chairs, surrounded by colorful enclosures that enlivened the street. But despite the attractiveness of the people spots, local merchants say neither structure attracted much use.

Passersby assumed they were private sidewalk cafes for the two sit-down eateries. But Chicago’s rules governing people spots—established in 2012 to encourage the development of these miniature public spaces—prohibit table service and alcohol consumption, so the seating wasn’t much use for restaurant patrons.

A total of eight parklets have been installed across the city, from Andersonville and Lakeview to Kenwood and Grand Boulevard. Those that feature tables and chairs and have been placed next to coffee shops and take-out joints have been popular with customers. Other people spots that don’t resemble sidewalk cafes, such as “the Wave,” an installation of free-form seating at Addison and Southport, have also inspired plenty of positive loitering.

But since the Lakeview people spots weren’t successful, staffers at the Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce came up with a solution: push for new legislation that would allow restaurants like El Nuevo Mexicano and Pizza Metro to serve food and booze in private parklets dubbed “curbside cafes.”

15216828137_471a4c26e9_o
The curbside cafe in front of El Nuevo Mexicano. Photo: John Greenfield

“I thought this would be a big win for everyone, because it would generate additional sales tax revenue and bring more foot traffic to the strip,” says chamber head Maureen Martino.

In January, the City Council passed the “curbside cafe” ordinance, allowing restaurants and bars with narrow sidewalks to create private seating for customers in the parking lanes in front of their storefronts.

There’s just one problem: the new law is so narrowly written that it’s almost impossible to find a location that meets its requirements. As a result, that stretch of Clark in Lakeview will probably be the only location to get the blacktop bistros this year.

For starters, the ordinance states that these new curbside cafes can only be installed on the city’s officially designated pedestrian streets (aka “P-streets”)—business strips where new car-centric development like strip malls and drive-throughs are banned. Moreover, they’re only allowed at locations where the sidewalk is less than eight feet wide.

And while the sports-bar-filled stretch of Clark south of Wrigley Field is a P-street with narrow sidewalks, the ordinance bans the parklets within 1,200 feet of the ballfield.

They’re also forbidden within Chicago’s central business district.

“It’s going to be difficult to navigate all those parameters,” says 32nd Ward alderman Scott Waguespack. Although he feels curbside cafes could be a boon for retail strips, few locations in Bucktown and Logan Square would qualify.

And even though 44th Ward alderman Tom Tunney cosponsored the ordinance, some of his own constituents can’t have them. Tunney’s chief of staff, Bennett Lawson, says a couple of businesses on Halsted in Boystown contacted his office about doing curbside cafes. But their sidewalks are wider than eight feet.

Read the rest of the article on the Reader website.

  • The foot traffic problem with the 2800 and 2900 blocks of Clark are in no small part due to the Century Mall conundrum. The property seems to go through an identity crisis at least once a decade, it is, literally, a shell of what it once was.

  • tooter turtle

    The parking garage entrance really breaks up the block, too, in a bad way.

  • Michael Ashkenasi

    Agreed, Carter. As someone who grew up in Lakeview about 10 blocks away from the mall, Century has been pretty much the go-to place in the area to see indie movies. However, it always baffled me why they built a garage with so many spaces. Even on the rare occasions I drove to Diversey/Clark/Broadway, parking was never much of an issue…

  • what_eva

    I’ll disagree with that. Street parking in that area is difficult. My wife and I would usually take trans to Century, but one frigid Friday evening a few months ago, we decided to drive to see a movie. Big mistake, finding any spot was difficult for a couple of blocks around. I have a 383, so I could do side streets north of Diversey but not south.

  • Why would you ever park anywhere but the garage if you’re going into the Century?

  • what_eva

    Because the garage sucks and is expensive.

  • As it always was. Building the garage and then the (short-lived) food court likely cost a fortune and helped accelerated the demise of the mall in the form of noncompetitive rents. Such a shame, it was so lively back in the 80s.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Alderman Tunney: A People Spot Is More Valuable Than Parking Spots

|
32nd Ward Alderman Scott Waguespack, usually a progressive on transportation issues, recently made some backward comments about city initiatives that convert car parking spaces into facilities like Divvy stations, bike parking corrals and People Spot seating areas. Waguespack fretted about the impact these conversions would have on local businesses, but it’s clear that these innovative […]

The Case of the Missing Andersonville “People Spots”

|
[This article also runs in Checkerboard City, John’s transportation column in Newcity magazine, which hits the streets on Wednesday evenings.] As the Tribune’s Blair Kamin recently pointed out, it’s embarrassing that San Francisco will soon have more than eighty “parklets”—parking-lane space repurposed as picturesque seating areas—while our much-larger city only has a handful of them. Dubbed “People […]